RFK Jr’s pernicious campaign against ultra processed foods

The current attack on ultra processed foods by RFK Jr is just a simpleminded binary. He’s treating food as medicine and then vilifying certain ingredients as bad or dangerous. What do you expect from someone with no training in public health?

Take food coloring. Ever look at the pills you take: Advil, decongestant, laxative? Those colors are artificial. How are they safer than the same dyes added to breakfast cereals? Did you know that most baked goods contain acrylamide, a neurotoxin? Did you know that most commercial rice in the US has significant levels of arsenic? Did you know that grilled meats contain polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, which include known carcinogens?

 

“In reference to the Make America Healthy Again (MAHA) campaign targeting UPFs, David Ludwig, MD, PhD, a professor of Pediatrics at Harvard Medical School, wrote in the Washington Post, "Ultra-processed food has replaced fat as the new dietary villain...The rush to enact these measures could cause more harm than good." The MAHA report on childhood health released in May is a precursor to the nutritional guidelines update expected this fall.

 

“Meanwhile, American Medical Association President Bobby Mukkamala, MD, pointed out that, while some UPFs have little nutritional value, others are beneficial, such as folic acid-enriched cereal. This also applies to grain products that are part of the highly successful FDA-mandated effort to prevent neural tube defects, and vitamin B12 fortification, which is intended to prevent pernicious anemia.”

If RFK Jr really cared about making American healthy, he’d be pushing childhood vaccines instead of questioning them. He’d be doing everything he could to get Americans vaccinated against COVID. He’d be telling everyone, including Donald Trump, to minimize their fat intake, maintain a healthy weight and stop taking ketamine.

RFK Jr is pushing the Trump agenda of sowing chaos and confusion. Fire the experts and replace them with ignorant amateurs. Denigrate expertise. Replace standards of evidence with standards of political loyalty.

Look, I don’t make any money off the sales of brightly colored breakfast cereals that contain ultra processed ingredients. I don’t eat them and never have. But as a biochemistry professor, I’ve seen no evidence that America’s health is threatened by kids eating Froot Loops for breakfast from time to time. And I’ve seen nothing from the RFK Jr propaganda machine to convince me otherwise.

https://www.medpagetoday.com/opinion/second-opinions/118032?xid=nl_secondopinion_2025-10-26&mh=eb71348a5ff6ae370cc6759bc5dc3300&zdee=gAAAAABm4u1YoCP4y5SBTJUyUyqo9KxZhft26L1xeGdP0BzzQQN1Pb_ifR6vFqhFh-3U6Q_nU7DbA-EawzzXKxSRhMOwjrOGuOKbf7OE641eN0HfnK6eObE%3D&utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=WeekendOpinions_102625&utm_term=NL_Gen_Int_SecondOpinion_Active

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The ruble is collapsing

In 1998, I traveled to Moscow for the first time to teach in a summer course at the Russian Academy. The week before, we were on vacation and I heard on the radio “Today, the ruble lost 100% of its value.” This news was arresting—it meant that the ruble was worthless. That seemed unlikely. Indeed, the next day, the announcer apologized and said she meant to say that the ruble lost 50% of its value.  In the event, by the time I arrived at the Hotel Sputnik in Moscow, all the cash machines in the city were shut down. Restaurant prices changed hourly during my five-day stay, and there were sidewalk signs posting exchange rates that were written in chalk so they could easily be edited. Certainly puts our recent experience with inflation in perspective.   Over at jabberwocking.com, Kevin Drum notes that the ruble is down 30% since the war started and 20% just since September.   From the comment thread: “The problem with the Russian economy at this point is that it is basically...
Read more

I agree with RFK Jr.

Though it feels weird to say it, RFK Jr and I agree on something: curtailing direct-to-consumer marketing of pharmaceuticals. “ The Trump administration is discussing policies that would make it harder and more expensive for pharmaceutical companies to advertise directly to patients, in a move that could disrupt more than $10 billion in annual ad spending.   Although the US is the only place, besides New Zealand, where pharma companies can directly advertise, banning pharma ads outright could make the administration vulnerable to lawsuits, so it’s instead focusing on cutting down on the practice by adding legal and financial hurdles, according to people familiar with the plans who weren’t authorized to speak publicly on the matter.   “The two policies the administration has focused in on would be to require greater disclosures of side effects of a drug within each ad — likely making broadcast ads much longer and prohibitively expensive — or removing the industry’s ability to d...
Read more

The big C

Nobody wants to get cancer. And there is no sure path to avoiding cancer. There are a number of gene alleles that predispose to cancer risk. If you inherit one of these alleles, your risk of cancer is higher than average. That doesn’t mean you can’t do anything. Knowing you’re at higher risk means you should undergo more frequent testing (breast imaging, colonoscopy, prostate exams, etc). Early detection improves survival. There are a number of other “lifestyle” risk factors for cancer: smoking, alcohol, sun exposure, obesity and aging. Of course, if your goal is a long life, you’ll have to confront an increased risk of cancer as you age. Again, surveillance is an important way to increase survival. Diet is probably the most modifiable cancer risk factor.  “ The most recent research uses different indices to assess dietary patterns without specifying the amount of animal-based foods that participants consumed. A   2023 meta-analysis   included assessment of 22 prospective...
Read more