High intelligence doesn’t predict good judgement
I taught medical students for over 30 years. The bar to admission at Saint Louis University Medical School was pretty high for metrics like GPA and MCAT scores. But as a professor, I realized that crossing those bars was no guarantee of sound judgement. Erica Schwartz, Trump’s CDC director nominee, wasn’t a SLUSOM grad*, but she is a case study supporting my contention that, in humans, the traits of high intelligence and good judgement are unlinked. “As the hearing proceeded, I began to hear rumblings in my public health group chats. The hearing was not going well. Schwartz was failing to give straightforward answers to lay-ups. Clips began appearing on my social media feeds. It was not good . Before long, it looked like a complete implosion. “Schwartz would not give clear statements debunking links between vaccines and autism. Ouch. “She did not know that the CDC's Office on Smoking and Health is, for all practical purposes, closed . (This i...